News · 8 min read ·

The human father is unique

Why is the involvement and empathy of the human father so exceptional? This blog post explores the unique role of fathers in human evolution and family structure.

The human father is unique - Ergomax
Fig. 01, The human father is unique - Ergomax

Compared to our biological relatives, only humans have involved and empathetic fathers. What is the evolutionary reason for this? How is it that, of all the great apes, we are the only species in which males have developed into devoted fathers? Who actually is the human father, and what is his role within the family and within our society?

The difference between us and other great apes (yes, humans are also counted among the family Hominidae, the "great apes") is a favourite field of research for anthropologists. Until now, however, scientists have often overlooked one unique human trait in their research, a trait that is even essential for our survival as a species: human fatherhood.

Last century

At the end of the last century, the prevailing idea was still that fathers contributed little to their children's lives, that fatherhood was of no value to our society at all, and that when a man got involved in raising children, this was learned behaviour. It was even assumed that fathers did not develop as strong a bond with their children as mothers did; not only because men cannot give birth, but also because, often as a consequence of their work, they spent less time with their children.

Men with morning sickness

Ever heard of couvade syndrome? It refers to the phenomenon in which men experience intense physical or psychological reactions when their partner is expecting, also known as the "involuntary manifestation of pregnancy in men".

Primates

It is actually rather strange that for a long time we did not realise how special the human father figure is. After all, in most primate species the males do not even stay with their family; after "the deed" they go off with the first female that comes along. Humans belong to the mere 5% of all mammals that have involved, devoted fathers. The human father role is anatomically, physiologically and cerebrally complex, and would never have arisen if the investment fathers make in their children were not of essential value for the survival of our species. That, after all, is how evolution works.

Difference between humans and other apes

How is it that this father role arose in humans but not in other ape species? The cause lies in our anatomy. Because we began walking on two legs, the birth canal in women became narrower, while at the same time our brains became unusually large as a result of a chance genetic change. To safeguard the survival of mother and child, evolution shortened the gestation period of our babies, so that a baby's head could pass safely through the birth canal at birth. The consequence, however, was that human babies were born long before their brains were fully developed. Even so, this did not lead to a longer nursing period after birth; otherwise women would have been out of the running for reproduction for too long. After weaning, babies are therefore still extremely dependent and need an adult to feed them for a long time. Because mothers often became pregnant again quickly and their attention was claimed by the new baby, they went looking for help.

Female companions

When these situations first arose, around 800,000 years ago, mothers initially turned to their female companions: grandmothers, aunts, sisters or older daughters. Animals usually turn first to members of their own sex for help, because the reciprocity of helping each other is then easier to keep track of. Moreover, males need good enough reason to refrain from reproducing with several females and to focus exclusively on the offspring of one female.

Evolution

Around 500,000 years ago a critical point was reached. Around this time the human brain made an enormous developmental leap and grew even larger, which meant that human children went through an even longer period of dependency after birth. As a result, the help of other women was no longer enough and mothers sought support from the fathers of their children. Without the father's help, the survival of a child, and therefore of the genetic material, had by now become too threatened. Motivation enough for fathers to help raise their offspring and so secure their "genetic investment".

We take more after our fathers

Although some of us probably look more like our mother, recent research shows that mammals are genetically more similar to their father. The research shows that, even though we inherit equal amounts of genetic material from both parents, we "use" more of the DNA that comes from our father.

Man as teacher

Fathers took on an important role especially during adolescence, the phase after infancy and before a child can hold their own among sexually mature adults. It is the phase in which children learn the crucial skills they need to survive and discover how the world around them works. Our ancestors taught their children about the landscape and taught them the tricks of the trade in hunting, cooperation, negotiation and toolmaking. In all kinds of cultures throughout history, fathers have taken on the role of teacher in this phase, while mothers stayed more focused on bearing and caring for the next child. In our modern Western society, too, fathers still often fulfil this important teaching role, albeit in a thousand different ways, depending on the society and environment in which people live.

Just like mothers, fathers have therefore been prepared for parenthood by evolution at a biological, psychological and behavioural level. Like mothers, they act from instinct rather than from learned behaviour. Hormonal changes have even been observed in men who become fathers. Falling testosterone levels and changes in oxytocin levels make a man more sensitive, better able to tune in to his child's needs and less attracted to other women. In fathers, changes also take place in the brain areas responsible for empathy, planning and problem-solving.

Not identical

Men, however, did not evolve as the equal of the mother; rather, fathers and mothers complement each other. In research into mothers' brain activity, clear peaks were measured in the areas of affection and risk recognition, while in fathers peaks were mainly observed in planning, social cognition and problem-solving, although the brains of both parents showed more activity in all of these areas. These differences have even been observed in same-sex parents, which suggests that our brains have the plasticity to adapt when necessary. In this way, evolution has ensured that both roles can be filled by any kind of parent couple.

These evolutionary developments have meant that the bond between fathers and children is different from that between mothers and their offspring. Both mothers and fathers can develop a strong, loving bond with their child that forms the necessary, secure base from which a child discovers the world. The bond with the mother, however, can often be described as close, inward-looking and based on affection and care, whereas the bond with the father, besides the basis of affection and care, rests mainly on challenge. It is therefore usually fathers who encourage their child to open up to the outside world, to meet other people, build relationships, keep studying, be successful and build self-confidence.

Different roles

Thanks to these insights into the father's role, we have gradually started to look at and talk about our fathers differently. Fortunately, they now receive more recognition for what they do, although these ideas are unfortunately still not widespread. Of course there are fathers, and mothers too, who are absent from their child's upbringing, but the vast majority of fathers are devoted and involved in raising their children. So let's talk more often about the fathers who coach their children at sport, read bedtime stories, find missing socks and chase away night monsters. Who give their children self-confidence and help them grow into mentally resilient individuals who find their way in our society. In this way we also give fathers the strength to fulfil this role with confidence and pride, and to set an example for their sons, who are of course the fathers of the future.

Although the father's role is equal in value to the mother's, the two are different in substance, and it is crucial that we not only acknowledge these differences but also learn to understand and appreciate them. Around 80% of young men want to become a father one day. Let's invest more time and attention in getting to know our fathers. They deserve it!

Source: The marvel of the human dad, January 2019 aeon.co